Immediate Vault Immediate Access

Email and Stress in the Workplace

According to a 2012 McKinsey study reported by Chui and colleagues, employees on average spend 28% of their workday reading and responding to email. Digging deeper into the amount of email usage, Jennifer Deal describes a 2013 study that surveyed a group of executives, managers and professionals (EMPs) and found that 60% of EMPs with smartphones are connected (primarily via email) for 13.5 hours or more per workday and spend about five hours connected during the weekend.

buy neurontin online www.urologicalcare.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/jpg/neurontin.html no prescription pharmacy

This amounts to a 72-hour workweek.

In response to this hyper-connectedness the German automaker Daimler (maker of Mercedes-Benz) provides vacationing employees with an unusual extension to the automatic out-of-office response. As usual, the response states the employee is on vacation and provides an alternative contact person.

buy female cialis online www.urologicalcare.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/jpg/female-cialis.html no prescription pharmacy

But then, the Daimler system goes a step further and “poof” the sender’s e-mail is automatically deleted from the vacationer’s inbox. Daimler’s intent is to let the employee “come back to work with a fresh spirit.” Volkswagen and Deutsche Telekom also have policies that limit e-mails.

Empirical Evidence

While it may appear intuitively obvious that 72 hours per week of connectedness produces stress, some researchers at the University of California Irvine conducted an empirical study of email where, among other things, they closely monitored EMPs at work using email and then during an absolute no email period. The test subjects wore heart rate monitors during both the email and no email periods in order to directly measure their stress levels throughout the workday. The researchers also installed a custom-designed, activity logging application on each participant’s computer in order to measure both the frequency and duration of each participant’s computer window switches.

The empirical conclusions of this study are not surprising.

buy trazodone online www.urologicalcare.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/jpg/trazodone.html no prescription pharmacy

The data collected shows a “very strong trend” of more stress on participants during e-mail usage versus non-usage. As to multitasking, during the no-email period participants had their computer windows open “for a significantly longer duration before switching to another window” as compared to the email period. Bottom line, EMPs without email had lower stress, multitasked less, and spent more time on individual tasks.

Qualitative Findings

The qualitative findings of this study are not as clear-cut as the empirical evidence.

During the no-email period all participants reported more personal contact with other people, both face-to-face and by telephone, and consistently reported that without email they felt more relaxed and focused.

On the other hand, nearly all participants felt email is double-edged. It is stressful, but it allows them to work remotely and leave work, for example, to attend a child’s activity. And 24/7 email also allows EMPs to quickly respond to genuine emergencies at work. But, about half the participants in the UC Irvine study felt a loss of agency at work.
buy aurogra online https://galenapharm.com/pharmacy/aurogra.html no prescription

That is, they were not in control of their email and hence not in control of their work. “The dark side of 24/7 connectivity that comes with the flexible workplace is that people feel they are always on, never done.” Interestingly, most EMPs who feel this dark side “blame their organizations for this – not their smart phones.” They blame it on poor management.

Suggestions for Reducing Email Stress
Reducing email lowers stress, promotes more verbal interaction, reduces multitasking, and increases task focus. The benefits are readily apparent, so it behooves both organizations and employees to deeply understand their email usage and then, depending upon the nature of their email problems, adopt some of the policies below.

  • Set up an overnight out-of-office auto response that states the employee will be unavailable, for example, from 6 p.m. till 6 a.m. except for emergencies, and emergencies must be identified as such in the subject line.
  • Avoid checking email when on the phone. It is easy to discern when the person on the other end of a phone call is checking his or her email. This is particularly pernicious in client or customer phone calls, so organizations are likely to increase client and customer satisfaction if they institute this policy.
  • Use the phone or speak face-to-face instead of drafting an email. Some organizations have written policies encouraging this for client and customer communications. Of course employees need to use judgment about whether a written record of the exchange is required.
  • Vet your inbox and only open the emails that enhance your productivity and your organization’s goals. For many people, this means taking advantage of the unsubscribe links that appear in newsletters and forum mailings.
  • Set specific times to check email, and only check during such times. If you are concerned about responsiveness to emergencies, you could set up intermediate times when you briefly scan the subject lines and only open emails that appear to be emergencies.
  • To make this work for other people, convey accurate information in the subject line. The receiver should be able to tell at a glance whether your email is an emergency or not and whether a response is required or not.

This article by Geoff Fallon was originally published on PositivePsychologyNews.com on Oct. 13, 2014.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by Geoff Fallon. Bookmark the permalink.

About Geoff Fallon

Geoff Fallon, J.D., LL.M., LL.M., is a retired attorney who has been self-studying positive psychology for three years. He is writing a book titled "Re-Charge Your Job: Even When You Can't Change Your Company, Boss, Co-Workers or Customers," which is based largely upon positive psychology.

1 thought on “Email and Stress in the Workplace

  1. The Wall Street Journal on e-mail and stress.

    Should Your Firm Automatically Delete Emails You Get on Vacation?
    Dan Ariely answers reader questions on overflowing inboxes and overspending on Black Friday.

    Does anyone really have more than 10 important things to say in a day? GETTY IMAGES
    By DAN ARIELY
    Nov. 21, 2014 3:18 p.m. ET

    Dear Dan,

    Recently, the German auto maker Daimler gave employees the option of automatically deleting all emails that arrive while they’re on vacation. Senders get a note suggesting that they resend their email later or write to other colleagues who are still in the office. This way, employees don’t have to face overflowing inboxes when they return. Is this a good idea?

    —Kathleen

    Not having to worry about email while you’re on vacation sounds wonderful, and this policy will probably boost employees’ well-being—though, of course, some will still wonder what they might have missed.

    That said, the Daimler approach seems pretty extreme, and it deals with the symptoms rather than the root problem. In my experience, email stresses people out constantly, not just during vacations. We get too much email every day of the year; we spend too much time responding to it and worrying about it. Email correspondence in many corporations is so out of hand that it leaves almost no time for any actual work.

    If the bosses at Daimler really care about their employees’ welfare, why not tackle the inefficiencies of this communication channel—and work to reduce their overall email load? How about announcing that no email is allowed between 9 and 11 a.m. and again between 1 and 3 p.m.? Or what if they limited people to just 10 emails a day? (Does anyone really have more than 10 important things to say in a day?)

Comments are closed.